WholesomePaths WholesomePaths
Join the Community
Relationships · Guide

His Secret Obsession Alternatives: 5 Better-Grounded Books

His Secret Obsession alternatives: five well-regarded relationship books, what each covers, who it suits and its limits. No affiliate links to books.

October 30, 2026 · 9 min read · Written and reviewed by the WholesomePaths team

If you want a more grounded read than a dating guide built on one author’s theory, five books stand out: The Seven Principles for Making Marriage Work, Attached, Hold Me Tight, Nonviolent Communication and Mating in Captivity. Each was written or co-written by a researcher, psychiatrist, psychologist or couples therapist. All of them are about both partners, not about getting one person to feel a certain way.

You can read them instead of a paid program, or alongside one. Below is what each book covers, who it suits, and where it falls short.

This post contains links to our reviews. If you buy through a link on those pages we may earn a commission, at no extra cost to you. How we make money.

Key takeaways

  • Best all-rounder for couples: The Seven Principles for Making Marriage Work by John Gottman and Nan Silver.
  • Best for dating and “why do I feel so anxious?”: Attached by Amir Levine and Rachel Heller.
  • Best for feeling disconnected: Hold Me Tight by Sue Johnson.
  • Best for saying hard things kindly: Nonviolent Communication by Marshall Rosenberg.
  • Best for long relationships that feel flat: Mating in Captivity by Esther Perel.
  • No book can make a specific person commit, return or change. These books help you understand yourself and talk better.

Why look for an alternative to His Secret Obsession?

His Secret Obsession is a $49 digital guide by relationship coach James Bauer, with a 60-day refund. It’s built on his “hero instinct” idea: that men feel closer to a partner when they feel needed and appreciated. Some of its communication advice is reasonable. But the hero instinct is the author’s own framework, not an established psychological model, and the sales page promises that a specific man will commit. No guide can do that. We explain the idea in our hero instinct explainer.

People usually want an alternative for one of three reasons: something based on research, advice that works for any partner, or a two-way approach to the relationship. The five books below cover all three.

A stack of plain hardback books beside a mug of tea on a wooden table by the window

1. The Seven Principles for Making Marriage Work (John Gottman and Nan Silver)

What it is: a practical guide from John Gottman, whose research team spent decades observing how couples talk and argue. The Gottman Institute describes it as an overview of the concepts, behaviours and skills that help couples build a lasting relationship, with questionnaires and exercises you do together. The revised edition was published by Harmony (Random House) in 2015 (The Gottman Institute).

Why it’s useful: it’s built on observation, not theory alone. One well-known Gottman idea is the “bid”, any small attempt to get a partner’s attention or affection. In a six-year follow-up of newlyweds, couples who stayed married had turned toward each other’s bids 86% of the time; couples who divorced averaged 33% (The Gottman Institute, “Turn Toward Instead of Away”).

Downsides: the title says “marriage”, and the examples lean that way. It’s most useful if you’re already in a committed relationship and your partner will do some exercises with you.

Best for: couples who want a structured, research-based place to start.

2. Attached (Amir Levine and Rachel Heller)

What it is: a book that applies adult attachment research to dating and relationships. Levine is a psychiatrist and neuroscientist; Heller is a psychologist. It describes three styles, anxious, avoidant and secure, and helps you spot your own and your partner’s. It’s published by Tarcher, an imprint of Penguin Random House (NetGalley publisher listing; the book’s website).

Why it’s useful: if you’ve ever wondered why closeness makes one partner reach for more and the other step back, this book gives you words for it. Many readers find that alone takes some of the sting out.

Downsides: it’s easy to over-use the labels. Researchers usually measure attachment on two sliding scales, anxiety and avoidance, rather than as three fixed boxes (Simpson and Rholes, 2017, Current Opinion in Psychology). Read it as a lens, not a verdict on your partner.

Best for: people who are dating, or who feel anxious when a partner goes quiet. It pairs well with our guide on why he pulls away after you get close.

3. Hold Me Tight (Sue Johnson)

What it is: a book built around seven conversations for couples. Sue Johnson, who died in 2024, was a clinical psychologist and researcher who developed Emotionally Focused Therapy (EFT). Its central idea is that partners are emotionally attached to and dependent on each other, and that couples do better when they are open, attuned and responsive. The conversations include “Recognizing the Demon Dialogues”, “Finding the Raw Spots”, “Revisiting a Rocky Moment”, “Forgiving Injuries” and “Keeping Your Love Alive”. It was published by Little, Brown Spark in 2008 (Hachette Book Group).

Why it’s useful: it explains the cycle where one partner protests and the other shuts down, and treats it as a shared pattern rather than one person’s fault.

Downsides: it asks for real emotional honesty, ideally from both of you. If you’re reading alone, some chapters can feel like homework for two.

Best for: couples who love each other but feel stuck in the same painful loop.

4. Nonviolent Communication (Marshall Rosenberg)

What it is: a communication method developed by Marshall Rosenberg, PhD, set out in Nonviolent Communication: A Language of Life, now in its third edition from PuddleDancer Press (PuddleDancer Press; Center for Nonviolent Communication). The method is usually taught in four parts: what you observe, how you feel, what you need, and a clear request.

Why it’s useful: it’s a skill you can use with a partner, a parent or a colleague. It turns “You never help” into something closer to “When the dishes are still out in the morning, I feel worn out. I need us to share it. Would you do them on weeknights?”

Downsides: it isn’t written only for couples, and the phrasing can feel stiff until it becomes natural. Research on it is still small: one randomised study of 51 nursing students found better empathy and relationship scores after an NVC programme, but no change in stress (Park et al., 2025, Iranian Journal of Public Health).

Best for: anyone whose arguments start well and end badly. Our guide on how to ask for what you need without starting a fight uses the same ideas.

5. Mating in Captivity (Esther Perel)

What it is: couples therapist Esther Perel’s book on the tension between security and desire in long-term relationships. It was first published by Harper in 2006 (Reading Group Guides). Drawing on her clinical work, Perel asks whether we can want what we already have, and how couples can keep playfulness and curiosity alive (estherperel.com).

Why it’s useful: it’s honest that comfort and passion pull in different directions, and it doesn’t blame either partner for that.

Downsides: it’s more essay than workbook, so there are fewer step-by-step exercises. It’s aimed at established couples, not people in early dating.

Best for: long-term couples who get on well but feel more like flatmates than partners.

A couple reading a book together on a sofa in a calm living room

Quick comparison

Book Written by Best for Style
The Seven Principles for Making Marriage Work Researcher John Gottman with Nan Silver Committed couples Practical, with exercises
Attached Psychiatrist Amir Levine and psychologist Rachel Heller Dating, anxiety about closeness Explainer with self-checks
Hold Me Tight Psychologist Sue Johnson Couples stuck in a painful loop Seven guided conversations
Nonviolent Communication Marshall Rosenberg, PhD Any relationship, hard conversations Method and examples
Mating in Captivity Couples therapist Esther Perel Long-term couples, desire Reflective essay
His Secret Obsession Relationship coach James Bauer Women wanting concrete phrases to try with a man Digital guide, $49, 60-day refund

Instead of His Secret Obsession, or as well?

Instead, if you want advice grounded in research, if your partner isn’t a man, or if you’re tired of advice about one person “making” another feel something.

As well, if you like concrete wording and quick reads. His Secret Obsession offers ready-made phrases; the books above explain why connection works. Used together, the books can keep the phrases honest. The test is simple: would you be comfortable if your partner knew why you said it? If yes, it’s communication. If no, skip it.

For more practical guides, visit our relationships section.

When a book isn’t enough

If you keep having the same fight, a couples counsellor or licensed marriage and family therapist can help in ways a book can’t. If you feel controlled, afraid or hurt, that isn’t a communication problem. In the US, the National Domestic Violence Hotline is free, confidential and open 24/7: call 800-799-7233 or text START to 88788. Elsewhere, contact your country’s domestic abuse helpline, or your local emergency number if you’re in danger.

FAQ

What’s the best book like His Secret Obsession?

If you want something focused on attraction and dating, Attached is the closest in topic. If you’re in a committed relationship, start with The Seven Principles for Making Marriage Work.

Are these books only for women?

No. All five are written for anyone, and most work best when both partners read them.

Are there research-based relationship books?

Yes. Gottman’s book draws on his team’s observational research with couples. Attached and Hold Me Tight draw on attachment research. That doesn’t promise results, but it means the ideas rest on more than one author’s theory.

Do you earn money from these books?

No. We don’t link to the books with affiliate links. We may earn a commission if you buy His Secret Obsession through our review page.

Our honest take

For most people, a well-researched book is a better first step than a paid program. If you still want concrete phrases to try, His Secret Obsession is cheap and refundable, but read our His Secret Obsession review first so you know what it can and can’t do.

Want more honest guides like this? Join the WholesomePaths newsletter. One email. Three areas of growth. Zero spam.

Keep exploring

Body, relationships, and mind move together — one article is rarely the whole picture.

Health & Fitness → Spiritual Growth → Join the Community

You might also like